a blog created for UCF Theories of Masculinitiy students to share experiences, resources/links, articles/reviews, to rouse discussion and incite action, and engage issues related to masculinity. you should participate, too. email moderator for permission at Leandra@ucf.edu.
Monday, April 21, 2014
How to be a Feminist …. For MEN
I have posted two different links to two articles talking about how to be a better feminist man. However, i think they represent a lot of hostility, and both seem to come with different tones and messages.
Who says I'm always negative? Leaving aside the substantial evidence in the form of blog posts, angry Twitter rants and the rages that overtake me when my football team isn't winning, I assure you I'm capable of being reasonable, constructive and even -- make sure you're sitting down for this -- pleasant.
You may be under the impression that I hate men. This is not the case. Men are fine! (Some men are really fine, if you get what I'm saying, which I'm sure you do, because that had all the subtlety of a large-scale trainwreck.) What makes me mad is misogyny. What makes me madder is the appropriation of the feminist movement by men who either don't know what they're doing or are deliberately trying to profit from it.
Let's say you're the first kind -- well-meaning, but just not that well-educated about what being a feminist entails. You've come to the right place! I'm going to stop yelling for long enough to tell you ten things you can do in order to be a better feminist, a better ally and -- let's face it -- a better person.
1. Leave your baggage at the door.
I know you have a bunch of preconceptions about what feminism is and what your place in the grand scheme of things might be. That's perfectly natural -- all of us have preconceived notions about the world based on our prior experiences. But I'm gonna need you to drop all of that when you walk into feminist spaces.
Feminism is a movement that is largely based on female lived experiences. If you're not a woman, you can empathize, but you simply can't say you know what we've been through. And that's fine! There are plenty of causes I support even though I'm not directly linked to them or affected by them. Nobody's saying you can't be a feminist. What we're saying is that you need to follow our lead on this one, because this movement is about the way power structures affect our lives in ways that you may not even be able to perceive from where you're standing.
Come in with an open mind and be ready to learn, and you'll find yourself not only having your eyes opened to a whole new world, but being much more capable of understanding and processing what you'll see and hear.
2. Be prepared to do a lot of listening.
You probably have a lot of insights that you want to share. You want to tell us why men act the way they do and how you think we can change that behavior. And there's room for that in feminism... to an extent. But for the most part, what we need men to do is just to listen.
I want you to think about all the women who are denied a chance to speak by men around the world -- women who are barred from obtaining an education, women who are subjected to genital mutilation, women who aren't allowed to work, women who are survivors of sexual abuse, women of color, trans and queer women, sex workers. Don't they deserve a chance to be heard? Wouldn't you like to be the person to give them that chance?
It seems simple, but it's so, so important. A huge part of being an ally is being prepared to listen to our stories -- and there are a lot of them. A lot. You might want to get out a notepad and start taking notes. There may or may not be a test later.
We have been silenced for so long. Let us speak. Please.
3. Don't expect an automatic welcome.
You're a stand-up guy, right? Here you are, ready to roll up your sleeves and get your hands dirty fighting the good fight. If only more guys were like you!
The thing is -- and don't take this personally -- we've seen a lot of guys who looked just like you, talked just like you, were just as enthusiastic as you... who proceeded to talk over us, silence us, demean us or use our movement to profit off us. Can you blame us for being a little wary? Can you blame us for being suspicious when men try to enter our spaces, no matter how seemingly good their intentions?
Under the guise of "feminism," men have sexually harassed and raped women whose trust they'd gained, used their positions of influence to bully and silence women (Hugo Schwyzer, anyone?) and even gotten away with murder. No, you probably won't do any of those things-- but we can't be sure of that. So be prepared for a little hostility. We've had to learn the hard way to be suspicious of strangers bearing gifts. If you work hard and do right by us, we'll accept you in time.
4. Don't expect special treatment.
This is something a lot of men struggle with, and with good reason -- they've come from a position of total privilege, where their ideas and opinions are automatically given weight by virtue of their gender. You might not even realize this, but your maleness gives you huge advantages out there in the big, wide world.
If you want to be a feminist, you have to be prepared to give that up.
It's hard. I know how hard it is, because there are times when I've had to do it myself. Sometimes you'll find yourself feeling offended or affronted. You'll find yourself wondering why you even bother if people aren't going to acknowledge your efforts. That's your privilege talking, and you need to learn to set all of that aside if you want to do this right.
Welcome to the new world, friend. Enjoy equality!
5. Don't talk over us.
A lot of men take offense to this, but you need to learn to bite your tongue.
This is our movement. We're glad that you're along for the ride, but you have to learn that you don't get to take center stage. That space is reserved for women with real lived experiences to share. If you find yourself with the urge to talk over a woman who's sharing her story, just...don't. There is no easier way of riling up a feminist than by trying to tell her story for her, or assuming you know it better than she does. I promise you, no matter what the situation is, you don't. You haven't lived her life, you haven't seen what she's seen or felt what she's felt, and there is no way that you, a man, can possibly understand 100 percent of what it's like to be a woman.
I'm not saying you're not allowed to speak. I'm saying you have to wait your turn. In feminist spaces, a woman's lived experience takes precedence over your insights as a man. We're kind of natural experts in this field, you know? Just let us talk.
6. Don't stay silent when you see sexism in action.
Your buddies all tell rape jokes. They make you feel awkward, but you don't say anything because you don't want to be That Guy -- the one who kills the buzz, the one who's the PC Police all the time. You smile awkwardly when your bestie tells women to make him a sandwich even though you think it's not really that funny, and you let yourself be drawn into discussions that degrade women even though that's not your intent.
Yeah, that needs to stop.
If you want to do something concrete -- and I'm guessing you do -- this is the best place to start. Call out sexism when you see it. Tell your buddies those rape jokes aren't cool. Roll your eyes at your friend's sandwich jokes and tell him he's being an ass. When you witness street harassment, step up and say something. Be the guy who doesn't let other guys talk shit about women behind their backs. Be the guy who never lets "she was asking for it" stand.
I can't stress enough how important this is. Your intent means nothing if you don't back it up. Help us out here, dude. Use your voice for good.
7. Never, ever mansplain to us.
You're talking to a sex worker who's sharing her story of what working life is like for her where she lives. You feel like she's getting some of the details wrong -- maybe you've understood a certain law differently from her, or you find it hard to believe the police are so unsupportive. You tell her you don't think that's the way things are and proceed to explain reality the way you've experienced it.
That's mansplaining, and you shouldn't be surprised if that sex worker gets more than a little testy when you do it.
I know some of you do this unintentionally, but you need to catch yourself doing it and stop. Mansplaining derails discussions, trivializes the lived experiences of women and is just outright rude. Do you honestly think you know more about the reality of sex work than the girl who was talking to you about it? She lives it. You've just seen a documentary on TV. She doesn't need you to explain to her what her life is really like.
8. Don't tell us to calm down.
I think I've kept my tone fairly light thus far, but most of the time, if I'm talking about social justice, I'm pretty goddamn angry. This is a natural response to being discriminated against for being a woman for my entire life. I know that anger can be very confronting and a little off-putting, but there are reasons for that, those reasons being that a) the reality of existence as a female in our society is pretty confronting, and b) being faced with brutal, unpleasant truths is naturally very off-putting.
You might be tempted to say something about catching more flies with honey. The thing is, we're not trying to catch flies. We're trying to change the world, and you don't change the world with niceness (believe me, even Gandhi was a manipulative old bastard -- no activist is ever as serene as they may seem). As my dad was fond of saying: the reasonable man adapts himself to the world, whereas the unreasonable man adapts the world to himself; therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
We're the unreasonable women, and we're adapting the world to ourselves, because that's how you get things done. Telling us to calm down is tone policing, and if you'd like an explanation of why that's a terrible thing to do, click that link above and prepare to feel like you've just been slapped in the face repeatedly by several angry women all at once.
Or you could take my word for it and just let us be mad when we need to be. Trust me, it works better this way. 9. Amplify and empathize.
If you find a great blog post about sex worker rights in India, share it with your friends. If someone you know is sharing their experiences as a trans woman going through the medical system, retweet the hell out of her and encourage people to follow her. If, say, a fiery young Muslim woman you know writes a great blog post that you find really useful, spread it around to everyone else you think might find it useful too. Allies are great amplifiers -- they help spread our message so that it reaches audiences it might not have reached otherwise. That's a valuable thing.
And while you might not understand what we've gone through or what it's like to be us, when we share our experiences, listen empathetically. It means a lot to know that even though you might not know how we feel, you care that we've felt pain and it pains you, too. Be there for us. March with us. Listen to us vent. Come along to our seminars and tell all your friends to come too. Be a part of the creation of safe spaces for us because you genuinely care about our safety and well-being. Be the great person I'm sure you're capable of being. This is what allies do.
10. Don't give up when it gets hard.
Not if -- when. Because it will get hard, I promise. You will be forced to re-evaluate almost everything you've ever known about women and feminism. You will learn about experiences that are totally alien to you. You will probably be taken down a peg or two when you mess up. (Don't worry, we all mess up, and we all eat crow afterwards. It's fine, the internet has a pretty short memory.) And once you start doing this, you can't just stop, because even if you want to, you won't be able to shut your eyes to reality once you've had them opened.
This is a war so many of us wish we didn't have to wage. I can't tell you how tiring it is to spend day after day after day having to fight for my fundamental human rights. It's draining and exhausting and, to be quite honest, pretty damn demoralizing sometimes. You won't experience all of that, but you'll experience enough to make you wonder why you got into this in the first place.
Here's why: because equality matters. This stuff isn't some kind of abstract academic debate. This is about the way 50 percent of the world is forced to live because of a system that regards them as second-class citizens. Isn't that wrong? Isn't that hateful? Shouldn't it change?
And wouldn't you rather be one of the people helping to change it?
Feminism is vital work. It's hard, it's messy, and it's often thankless, but it's also very, very necessary. It's necessary for all the reasons I've stated and re-stated on this blog dozens of times. It's necessary because when we don't do this work, people don't just suffer -- they die because of our inaction. And it's not just women who are affected -- it's every man ever criticized for choosing to stay at home with his kids, every man who likes crafts more than sports, every man who's ever cried in public, every man who isn't arrogant and self-assured enough to bluff his way through life as though he owns everything he sees. You might even be one of those men. If you are, this isn't just about us, this is about you. This is about a world in which we can all be free to express our genders however we like without facing judgement or discrimination for simply being who we are.
I want to live to see that world. I'm sure you do, too. So welcome aboard, friend. I'm glad you've decided to join us. Let's save the world together.
Aaminah Khan is a refugee support worker, writer and some-time human rights activist living in North Queensland. This piece first appeared on her blog,jaythenerdkid.wordpress.com.
1) Read as much as you can about feminist issues and feminist critical thinking … and keep reading. Not just mass media either. In fact, with a very few exceptions, reports about feminists and what they do in the mass media are apt to be oversimplified, sensationalised or outright sexist.
2) Talk to women and mostly listen. Or ask questions. Try not to presuppose. Be curious as opposed to critical – for your own education and our good.
3) Think for yourself but do it mostly by yourself. It’s your work, not the work of feminists, to educate yourself. Don’t come to us knowing nothing and acting as if you know everything. We are most often treated by men as if we are in need of their advice and direction and we might just be a little sensitive about this. It’s YOUR job to treat us as true equals – because we are – and because when it comes to women’s lives we know more than you do. It’s true that we’ll make lots of mistakes – just like you. It’s not your job to tell us what they are. We are an exploited and oppressed sex class and it is up to us to define the terms of our own liberation.
4) There are differences among feminists in terms of our analyses and the strategies and tactics we decide are appropriate for our own liberation. Choose those whom you wish to support and then support them by advocating amongst men. Keep your critiques of individual feminists or feminist perspectives to yourselves. As a result of our exploitation and oppression there is horizontal fighting and even bullying between us sometimes. Leave this to us to sort out. Your “contributions” to the fight only make matters worse, divide us further, force us to choose between our supporters, make male opinions the issue instead of feminist opinions and generally stall our efforts. If you think you have some brilliant insight or thought that no woman has had that can save our movement or send us unerringly in the right direction – I don’t believe you. But feel free to send us a secret message via a feminist friend.
5) It’s a fact that you will hear some women/feminists say things that sound negative toward men and about men. Leave it alone. It is the result of our experiences of violence and oppression. There isn’t one single woman who isn’t placed somewhere on the continuum of violence against women either as a direct or vicarious victim. Let us deal with it and accept that a generations-long system of oppression and violence has done its work on some of us. Wait for us. And don’t take it personally – it just makes you sound defensive and it lengthens the time it takes for each of us to come to terms with our lives and the lives of our sisters. Be particularly attentive to this with women whom you know have experienced violence and those of us who work with them.
6) If you feel divided from women and excluded from feminism sometimes, for gawd sakes deal with it. Women are divided from men and excluded from social, cultural, economic and political life in a thousand ways. We have to deal with it. You should be able to do that much. And use it to motivate your actions on behalf of our liberation.
7) If you’re afraid to stand up against sexism, male violence against women and the exploitation of women – how do you think we feel? Speak up and speak out.